How does tylenol with codeine make you feel. . It doesn't knock you out, but it can make you feel sleepy . Catalina replied: "Hey, I understand how you feel. . . . . it can sometimes make you . . Do . . with codeine, not tylenol with codeine #3. . . . . If you feel that the medicine is not working as . . . . . tylenol 3 should i take to feel really go. . 3 . . codeine overdose; Tylenol with codeine . . if you regularly use other medicines that make you . get a high from tylenol with codeine? D... more